Youth Sport Questioning Aids Decisions but Cognitive Mechanisms Remain
A critical review on youth sport instruction finds that coaches frequently use questioning during training and that game-based approaches incorporating guided questions often show improved tactical decision-making. However, the research also concludes that existing studies haven’t isolated the cognitive mechanisms, nor proved that questioning itself directly causes the gains. The review covers athletes aged 11 to 18 in soccer, basketball, and volleyball, noting that many interventions combined questioning with changes to rules, space, and teaching design, making cause-and-effect unclear. A pooled meta-analysis of 28 investigations with 1,600 participants reported an 11.41 percentage-point advantage in tactical decision-making, but it couldn’t attribute improvements specifically to questioning. Observations of 19 Australian youth soccer coaches found 71 questions per session (0.88 per minute), with only 7% of divergent questions explicitly prompting tactical problem-solving. The review also cites other studies where questioning-focused coaching education appeared feasible, but player decisions weren’t always measured.







