With a $4M price cut, infamous Paul Castellano mob mansion on Staten Island relists for $14M

A notorious Staten Island mansion tied to Gambino boss Paul “Big Paul” Castellano is back on the market after failing to find a buyer last year. The Todt Hill estate at 177 Benedict Road has been relisted for $13.995 million, down from a prior $18 million asking price in 2024. Built in 1980 and designed to resemble the White House, the property spans 33,000 square feet with eight en-suite bedrooms and 17 bathrooms. It sits on nearly 1.6 acres and includes Olympic-sized indoor and outdoor pools, a 13-car garage, and amenities such as a home theater, gym with sauna, and wine cellar. The listing agent, Rob Nixon, said the price better matches the current market and that replacement costs would be over $30 million.