Mother Jones' WNBA 'trans panic' story shows what happens when activism masquerades as journalism

A critique in the media industry focuses on Mother Jones’ coverage of XX-XY Athletics revenue, arguing its framing blurs activism and journalism. The piece says Madison Pauly’s headline describes Jennifer Sey as “profiting” from a “trans panic,” and suggests the story treats opposition to males competing in women’s sports as less legitimate, labeling critics as “anti-trans activists” or “MAGA trolls,” while portraying supporters as merely seeking safety. It also questions how “research” is presented, noting that a cited argument tied to protecting girls in locker rooms and athletes does not directly address whether sex should determine access. The critique discusses a cited 2026 JAMA Network Open review, saying results varied and the outlet omits key caveats.